Every content writer has watched it happen. You pour your heart into a piece, but before it sees the light of day, it gets stripped of its soul.
Keywords get shoved in where they don’t fit. Phrases are repeated ad nauseam. Before long, you aren’t sure if it’s a meaningful article or one of a billion SEO-focused pieces vomited onto the internet each year.
Across industries, creativity is being snuffed out in favor of pleasing the algorithms. As a lifelong writer, this is one of the worst realities I can imagine.
Ironically enough, it’s not even working.
SEO isn’t just killing creativity—it’s becoming less effective by the day. Google and other search engines are shifting focus, delving deeper into the realm of “AI answers,” and prioritizing big-name sites over small ones. The days of gaming the system with formulaic posts are over.
So why are clients still demanding SEO-focused nonsense instead of letting writers use our creativity to create impactful content? Better yet, how can you convince yours to let you add some creativity back into the marketing plan?
Let’s explore.
The Algorithm Isn’t Your Friend (Anymore)
You can’t have an SEO conversation without Google. For years, SEO has lived and died by its whims. The Holy Grail of content creation used to be ranking high enough for certain keywords to earn a click from searchers who think they’ve stumbled on the definitive answer to their query.
But Google’s priorities are evolving. Today, most search result pages are dominated by AI summaries or sponsored pages. Organic ranking doesn’t have the same punch as it used to.
With updates like the “Helpful” Content system and greater emphasis on E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trustworthiness), the search giant is rejecting content created solely to tick SEO boxes.
The internet we know is dying a slow, painful death. It’s being suffocated by a deluge of shallow, keyword-stuffed blog posts and websites. Worse, AI has catalyzed the rate at which brands can upload this content.
There’s no such thing as ranking an article strictly because you followed all the Yoast SEO best-practices.
Ask anyone in the content creation industry and they’ll probably tell you their organic search traffic has dropped this year. Aside from a handful of mega publishers, Google’s algorithm is no longer a reliable source of traffic—at least not via SEO.
Though algorithm changes and AI are influential factors, perhaps the more meaningful change is the way SEO-driven content strips writers of their creativity.
The Real Cost of Writing for the Algorithm
Writing has always been about telling a story. SEO gave us a formula for getting views by writing stories that appeal to an algorithm. But when we write strictly for SEO, what do we lose?
- Originality: The need to hit exact keywords forces writers to choose repetitive, uninspired phrasing. Compelling language and emotional connection often take a backseat to “target keywords.”
- Engagement: Have you clicked on an article in the number-one position only to find that it’s the same regurgitated fluff you see in every other post? I bet you’ve done that today. I have. That’s SEO writing at work—content for bots, not humans. You’d stop reading books if every story was predictably identical. So why should anyone bother reading web pages that are the same?
- Opportunities to Innovate: Sticking to a formula can blind writers to other approaches. Worse, you might have a better idea, but you may be prevented from executing it. An informative, keyword-heavy blog article isn’t always the best answer. Sometimes a controversial opinion piece or an eye-catching infographic is the better tool for the job. But the algorithm doesn’t like those as much, does it?
- The Joy of Writing: When was the last time you really enjoyed yourself while writing an SEO article? You might appreciate the paycheck, but the work itself isn’t usually exhilarating. Writing professionally isn’t always fun, but spending time on interviews, deep dives, or case studies can be a lot more engaging than writing for a search engine.
Perhaps the biggest loss here is connection. Readers aren’t algorithms. They’re people like you and me. When our writing panders to a search engine, we alienate the very audience we’re trying to attract.
Ouch.
What We Should Be Writing
Want to hear something ironic? Search engines are now prioritizing what us writers have known is best all along. Readers, too.
Authenticity.
Depth.
Value.
Content isn’t about hitting keywords anymore. It’s about matching the search intent of your audience and then delivering content that’s truly useful. One well-crafted, authoritative piece will outperform five keyword-stuffed articles every time.
Think of some of today’s most memorable brands. Apple. Coca-Cola. Nike. What do they have in common?
Answer: A story people remember and an ironclad identity.
Why should your content be any different? Just because you’re writing for a local dentist’s office doesn’t mean storytelling and identity are any less important. People want to know their teeth are in good hands, and they have plenty of choices. How does your article about plaque prevention win them over?
Don’t worry about the scale or the impact of one piece. Focus on creating long-term connections and delivering value at every touch point.
How to Reclaim Your Creativity
If you’ve been stuck in the SEO grind, breaking free can be daunting. Having clients strip your creativity away while you comply to make a living is soul-sucking.
The good news? Your creativity isn’t lost. You just need to reconnect with it.
Here are a few strategies to help you shake off the constraints of algorithmic thinking so you can reunite with your inner storyteller.
1. Don’t Shy Away From Experimentation
SEO writing tends to box us in with strict formats and expectations. Trying something new can help you break out. What if you write a piece with zero keywords? What if you transform a blog post into a narrative? Will humor or interactive features make your content stand out? By stepping outside your usual workflow, you can reignite your creative spark.
You’ll need to get clients on board, too.
So don’t be afraid to share your thoughts with them. Your client hired you as a writer because they trust your ability to create great content. Just because a job is pitched one way initially doesn’t mean it has to stay that way. Remind clients that effective content comes in many forms, and you might be surprised with how receptive they are.
2. Say “No” to Perfect
Aside from The Lord of the Rings trilogy (*wink*), there’s no such thing as a perfect story. The pursuit of algorithmic perfection stifles bold ideas. What if you wrote that article with a controversial angle or a storytelling twist that wouldn’t typically “rank well?”
Taking risks allows you to discover fresh perspectives and stand out in a sea of repetition. What client doesn’t want their content to stand out as bold and exciting?
3. Reconnect with Your Purpose
Why did you start writing in the first place? Reflect on the passion that brought you to this career. Do you love telling stories? Are you hoping for a chance to inform someone and positively affect their life?
Revisiting your motivations and letting them guide your work can help you escape from the dull cycle of SEO work. Not to mention, when your content comes from a place of authenticity, it resonates more deeply with your audience.
4. Collaborate and Learn
Sometimes the best way to refresh your creativity is to step outside your bubble and collaborate with peers or engage with communities in your niche. Seeing how others approach writing can inspire new ideas and help you break free from routine. You might even make some friends along the way.
Quick Exercise:
Before starting your next piece, jot down three ways you can make it uniquely yours. Maybe it’s your storytelling voice, a personal anecdote, or an unconventional format. Let these guide your creativity—and don’t worry if they don’t fit perfectly into SEO best practices. Your readers will thank you.
Write With Heart
Online content isn’t dead. But writing solely for SEO should be.
Search engines are changing, and so should we. Creativity and authenticity aren’t just feel-good buzzwords. They’re what audiences crave and they need to be the cornerstone of any content you create.
So go ahead. Break the mold. Trust that when you write with heart, your readers (and search engines) will reward you.
Like this article? Share it with your network! 👇👇