🐦‍⬛ They replaced me with AI. Now I charge them double

They replaced me with AI.
Now I charge them double.

· March 26th, 2025 ·

Hey friend 👋,

Sometimes even those bummers of a story have a happy ending. Like when you lose a client to AI, but they come crawling back and are now paying you double for the same work.

That’s what happened to me this week.

I think it teaches a very important lesson about AI, freelancing, and why high-quality writers should feel more confident than ever in this job market.

Speaking of those top-notch folks, I want to say a huge thank you to everyone who purchased our 2025 State of Freelance Writing report last week! The reception was outstanding, and I love hearing how it’s helping people understand the crazy market we’re in right now.

Hearing your feedback also has me thinking of some awesome content that we’ll be rolling out over the next few months!

But as always, my main goal is creating content that helps YOU.

So, what is your #1 freelance writing obstacle right now?

I’d love to hear about it and help you overcome it.

Just hit that reply button and let me know.

Best,

🐦‍⬛ Cody – Founder @ Ravenwood Writing Academy

Science-backed music made to help you focus

If you’re looking for a quick way to tap into that creative flow state, I can’t recommend Brain.fm enough. I’ve been listening to this app while I work for years. Nothing else quite compares.

It uses science-backed music in an array of genres (grooves and classical are my go-tos) for a tailored experience that helps you achieve focus, relaxation, or sleep in minutes.

Brain.fm was kind enough to extend Write Your Story readers an exclusive 30-day free trial, so click the link below to experience the benefits for yourself!

🧛 Freelance Bites:

News and Resources in 2 Minutes

  • Saying no to your client takes guts, but sometimes it’s the right move. Here are five tips for gracefully dodging that last-minute request (Content Marketing Institute).
  • Alex Lieberman (founder of Morning Brew) weighed in on the three channels he thinks will win in 2025. Spoilers, they all involve writing (HubSpot).
  • ICYMI: These three freelance myths hold countless new writers hostage. Don’t let them stop you from reaching your potential. #3 is probably one you didn’t see coming (Ravenwood Writing Academy Blog).

🧐 Your Questions, Answered

Have a question about freelance writing? Drop it in the form below and I’ll answer it in a future newsletter!

No one submitted a question last week. Want to ask one this time? I’d love to answer it in next week’s issue 😀

📬 Letters From My Desk

My Client Ditched AI and Hired Me Back. Now I Charge Them Double.

Six months ago, I lost a long-term client to AI.

They were an international company in the B2B technology space, and I had been writing deep-dive industry news articles and thought leadership pieces for them for over a year. The company exists in a highly technical niche with an audience of specialized engineers and COOs.

In an effort to cut costs, they replaced my role with AI.

Fast-forward to today, and guess who’s back on their payroll? Me. Doing the exact same work. But now, I’m charging twice as much.

Let’s talk about why.

We’re So Back

Earlier this week, I got an email from this client. They wanted to know if I’d be open to working together again.

They didn’t say, “Hey, the AI thing was a disaster, and we need you back!” but they didn’t have to. They wanted me to do the exact same work AI was supposed to handle.

I told them I was available but would only do the work for double my old rate.

They jumped on the deal. Zero pushback. No negotiation. They accepted immediately.

So what happened?

Where the AI Experiment Went Wrong

Like many companies, this client assumed AI could do what I did, just faster and cheaper. Feed it some prompts, get a full article in minutes, and save thousands of dollars a month in freelance costs.

Except… that’s not what happened. You knew that already. So what went so horribly wrong that now they’re thrilled to pay me twice as much to come back?

I checked out some of their AI-generated content. Spoilers, I saw some major issues:

No industry nuance – Their niche is very technical, with constant shifts in technology, global economics, and politics that impact buying decisions. AI might know a lot about a little. But it didn’t understand the complexities and produced overly simplified, generic writing.

Misinformation – AI doesn’t know things. It predicts words based on patterns. This meant the content often contained misleading or flat-out incorrect information. A layperson might not pick up on these errors, but an executive at a billion-dollar firm who reads this specialized content sure will. Which brings me to the next issue…

Lack of credibility – The audience for this content is made up of experts in their field. Anyone in their shoes could instantly tell the writing wasn’t coming from someone who actually understood the field. That’s a quick way to ruin your credibility and leave your audience looking for resources elsewhere.

Ultimately, I can’t even blame them. Plenty of people are misinformed about what AI can and can’t do. Brands are spending trillions on the current AI hype train—and leaves the ones who aren’t with some serious FOMO.

For this client though, the result was predictable. They thought AI would solve their problems, but quickly realized that bad content costs more than good content.

The Takeaway: Why AI Won’t Replace Great Writers

I don’t want this to come off the wrong way. I’m not the world’s greatest writer. I’m nowhere close to perfect.

But I had written in this niche for years, and built up a wealth of expertise along the way—not to mention a reliable network of sources. This allowed me to create insightful articles that connected with their audience and delivered tangible value.

This is why having a niche is so important.

AI can replace generalist writers who only cover surface-level topics. It’s good enough to do that somewhat convincingly.

But AI is not a replacement for expertise, nuanced insight, or writers with real understanding of a niche.

When businesses try to swap out skilled writers for AI, they often learn this lesson the hard way.

This isn’t a story about AI being useless. It’s a story about how good writers—those who bring real knowledge, critical thinking, and nuance—are more valuable than ever.

So if you’re worried about AI taking your job, take a look at your niche. If you don’t have a niche, the time to find one was yesterday.

It’s the best job security you can ask for. I’m extremely grateful for it.

Because in this case, AI didn’t take my job. It just proved why I deserved to be paid more for it.

Cody’s Top Picks

This is the part where I share some of the content I’ve been enjoying lately. Hope you enjoy!

(This section may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, I’ll earn a small percentage, which helps support this free newsletter at no extra cost to you.)

  • 📖 I’m Reading… Zero to One: Notes on Startups, or How to Build the Future.” I’m a nerd for business books and this one has been a refreshing change of pace. It’s all about thinking differently and harnessing the power of creation rather than following established footsteps.
  • 🎧 I’m Listening to…Nervous System” by Taylor Acorn and LOLO. Big fan of both of these artists, and when I woke up to this collab I knew it would be a good day.
  • 🌍 I’m Doing… House hunting in Seattle! We’re getting ready for a big road trip next when we move from NM to WA so this week has been busy lining up housing. I can’t wait to live within a 10 minute walk of like five ramen restaurants. RIP my waistline 🤷.
  • 🧠 You Should Remember:
A little more persistence, a little more effort, and what seemed hopeless failure may turn to glorious success.— Elbert Hubbard, American writer

💼 Jobs for Writers

1️⃣ Bisnow is looking for a freelance real estate writer to create content for their audience of more than 1.5M subscribers.

2️⃣ Stephanie Pitera Statile (Business Insider) is looking for a lived experience piece from a writer who has tried (or plans to try) the new Amtrak USA rail pass.

3️⃣ Column Five, a B2B marketing agency, is looking for a part-time copywriter that specializes in brand and content marketing for SaaS companies.

4️⃣ Alina Hamilton is looking for freelance resume writers for occasional work.

  • 💲 Pay Rate: $50 per resume (one draft and one final version)
  • See the original job posting on LinkedIn
  • Apply by sending Alina a message and sharing a portfolio with samples of past work.

5️⃣ Kendra Fortmeyer (DISCO) is looking for a freelance digital copywriter for 15-20 hours per week. Legal writing experience HIGHLY preferred.

  • 💲 Pay Rate: Undisclosed
  • See the original job posting on LinkedIn
  • Apply by DM’ing Kendra “a few sentences explaining how you meet the experience criteria above, plus a link to a writing sample.”

6️⃣ Claire Mainprize (The Good Information Foundation) is looking for a freelance writer with experience in lifestyle/culture. Must be based in Iowa, North Carolina, Wisconsin, or Texas.

  • 💲 Pay Rate: $300 per article
  • See the original job posting on LinkedIn
  • Apply by sending Claire a message at claire@goodinfous.org with relevant writing samples.

7️⃣ BuzzRx is looking for a contract-to-hire staff writer to create blog content in the consumer pharmaceutical space.

Subscribe to the newsletter

(It's free!)

Keep Reading. Keep Growing.

Get More Awesome Resources!

Get freelance writing tools, insights and freebies in your inbox weekly. No spam, ever. 

© DeBos Ventures LLC // Ravenwood Writing Academy 2024

0
No products in the cart.